JOKESTICK

Best friend gift ideas that aren't a candle

The best present for a best friend is one that uses what only you have: twenty years of stories, the first holiday, the text sent to the wrong person, the night that's never been explained. Anyone can buy them a candle. Only you can give them the version of themselves that you've been keeping. Here are the ideas that do that, from free to a weekend away.

Why are best friends so hard to buy for?

Because you know them too well. You know they've already got the thing, you know they'd never use the other thing, and you know exactly how their face goes when a present misses. The pressure is higher than for anyone else, and the shops are no help, because nothing in them was made with your friend in mind.

The way out is to stop looking for a thing and start looking at what you've got that nobody else has: the history. A present built from it can't be duplicated, can't be wrong, and usually costs less than the candle.

What are good gift ideas for a best friend?

The story, written down

Pick the one story you both tell, the one that gets longer every year, and write it properly: a few pages, with the bits they always leave out. Print it, bind it, or frame the first page. It will outlast anything else on this list.

The first photo and the latest, side by side

The earliest picture you have of the two of you, and the most recent, printed and framed together. Add the dates. It says everything a card can't.

A day you've been saying you'll do

Booked. Paid for. In the diary. The spa, the gig, the walk, the ridiculous afternoon tea, the trip back to the town you met in. Best friends say "we should" for years. Being the one who did is the present.

A box of the in-jokes

The sweets from the first holiday, the song on a seven-inch, the exact brand of crisps, a printout of the text, the fridge magnet from the terrible B&B. A shoebox of things that mean nothing to anyone else. They'll cry, in a good way.

A letter, for once

Not a card. A proper letter, two sides, about what they've been to you and the things you've never said out loud because you're British. Costs nothing, takes an evening, and gets kept in a drawer forever.

Their most-used phrase, made real

On a mug, a cushion, a tea towel, a doormat, a tiny neon sign. "I'm literally five minutes away." "I'll just have one." "It's not that far." Daft, cheap, and used every day.

A playlist with a sleeve

Every song from every era of the friendship, in order, with a printed sleeve explaining why each one is there. The explanations are the present.

Something made, badly

A cake you can't really bake, a scarf from a six-week knitting phase, a painting of their dog. The worse it is, the longer it stays on the wall.

A weekend away, just the two of you

If the budget allows, two nights somewhere neither of you has been, with no partners and no plan beyond a long dinner. It's the present that becomes a story for the next one.

What makes a best friend present land?

Specificity. If anyone else could have given it, it's a nice present. If it only makes sense coming from you, it's a good one. The best ones have a moment too: something opened, read or laughed at while you're in the room, or something that lands on their phone when you're not and makes them ring you straight away.

Teasing is allowed, encouraged even, as long as they're laughing hardest. Leave out exes if they're sore, health, money troubles and anything told in confidence, which, with a best friend, is a longer list than usual. You know where the line is. That's the point of you.

What should you avoid?

The candle, obviously. Anything with "best friend" printed on it. Jewellery with half a heart. Bath stuff. A voucher. All of them say you were in a hurry, and your best friend knows exactly what you look like in a hurry.

Jokestick: your best friend as a video game

We make Jokestick, so weigh this accordingly. It's a personalised retro video game starring your best friend, built from the stories only you two know: the first holiday as a level, the taxi that never came as a boss fight, the move from the school disco graded S to D. You're in the cast, and the rest of the gang can be too. Much of the comedy is the characters winding each other up in your own words.

You tell the stories to Joy, our interviewer, on your own phone and in your own time: start when you like, stop whenever, finish over a few evenings. Nobody else knows until it lands. Once you press Send it's ready within 48 hours, plays in the browser on any phone with no app, and one of us plays it through and reads every line before it reaches you. No exes, health, money or anything told in confidence; they should be the one laughing hardest.

Send the link just to them with no explanation and wait for the phone to ring, or drop it in the group chat and let everyone in. The Full Game is £45 for up to 8 people and the Director's Cut £79 for up to 14, so a two-hander with a couple of walk-ons is the cheapest edition. See what a best friend game looks like, or start on the home page.

See how it works