JOKESTICK

Gift ideas for a mate's 40th (that aren't another bottle)

The best 40th birthday present for a mate is one that's about them, not about the number: something that shows you remember who they were at twenty and know who they are now. A day out that takes them back, a proper upgrade of something they use every day, or a funny gift built from the jokes your group has been telling for years will beat a bottle every time. Here are the ideas that work, and how to choose.

What makes a good 40th birthday present?

By forty, most people buy themselves the things they want. So the present that lands is rarely the one that cost the most. It's the one that proves you've been paying attention for the last twenty years.

Three quick tests help. Is it about them, or about turning forty? A gift about the person beats a gift about the age almost every time. Will it still mean something in a month, when the cards have gone in the recycling? And could only you have given it? If anyone could have picked it up on the way to the party, it's a nice present. If it needed you, it's a good one.

None of that rules out a bottle, by the way. It just means the bottle shouldn't be doing all the work.

What can you get a friend turning 40 who has everything?

A day back in their twenties

Rebook the thing they loved at twenty-two. The five-a-side pitch they played on every Thursday, the seaside town from the first lads' or girls' holiday, the kind of small music night they used to go to every weekend. Organise it, invite the old crowd, and get the first round in. You're not giving them a day out so much as a day back.

Forty things you love about them

Forty short notes, handwritten, in a jar or a cheap notebook. Make them specific memories rather than compliments: "the time you drove halfway to Wales with the handbrake on" beats "you're kind" every time. It costs almost nothing, takes an evening, and it's the kind of present people keep in a drawer for decades.

A proper upgrade of something they use every day

Look at what they actually carry about. The wallet that's coming apart, the rucksack held together with hope, the kitchen knife that couldn't cut butter, the headphones with tape round the wire. Buy a really good version and tell them why you noticed. Practical, but it says you were paying attention.

A recreated photo

Dig out a photo from fifteen or twenty years ago: the same people, the same poses, ideally the same terrible outfits. Recreate it now and frame the two side by side. Everyone in it will want a copy, which is half the fun.

A lesson in the thing they always said they'd learn

Everyone has one. Pottery, sailing, DJing, bread, the guitar in the corner they bought at thirty. Book a taster session for two and go with them. If they love it, they've got a new hobby. If they don't, you've got a story.

The night sky, or the front page, from the day they were born

A print of the stars over their home town on the night they arrived, or a newspaper from the day itself. It's a classic for a reason: it's about them, it looks good on a wall, and it gets better the older they get.

A video from the people they've lost touch with

Track down the old flatmate, the friend who moved abroad, the manager from their first job, and ask each for a thirty-second happy birthday on their phone. Stitch them together and keep it quiet until the day. Nobody expects to hear from the people they haven't seen in ten years.

A weekend away with the old crowd

If the budget stretches and the group can club together, a couple of nights somewhere with a big table and a fire is hard to beat. Keep the plan simple and the cost clear from the start, so nobody drops out at the last minute.

Are funny 40th birthday presents a good idea?

Yes, as long as the joke is about them rather than at them. The over-the-hill gags (the walking stick, the "old git" mug, the giant badge) are fine for some people, but they're the same joke everyone else will make, and most of them were funnier when we were thirty and it was somebody else's birthday.

The funny presents that land are specific. The hobby they won't stop explaining. The noise they now make getting off the sofa. The "I'm five minutes away" sent from the other side of town. The holiday story they've told at every do since 2009. A joke only your group would understand is worth ten bought off a shelf.

A good rule: the person being teased should laugh hardest. Steer clear of health, money troubles, exes and anything told in confidence, and if you wouldn't want their mum to see it, it probably isn't a present.

How much should you spend on a friend's 40th?

There's no right number, and a thoughtful present on a small budget beats an expensive one bought in a hurry. If a group of you are clubbing together, agree an amount early, keep it voluntary, and let one person organise it so it doesn't drift. Shared money goes furthest on one thing they'll remember rather than lots of small things they won't.

Where does Jokestick fit?

This one is ours, so take it with a pinch of salt. Jokestick makes personalised retro video games starring a group of friends. The birthday one is the hero, the mates are the cast, and each running joke becomes a level: the dance they think they can still do, the new hobby, the story they always tell.

You tell the stories to Joy, our interviewer, on your own phone and in your own time: start when you like, stop whenever, finish over a few evenings if you want. Nobody else knows, which is the point. Once you press Send it's ready within 48 hours, plays in the browser on any phone with no app, and one of us plays it through and reads every line before it reaches you. A lot of the laughs come from the characters talking to each other and winding each other up, in the way your lot actually talk.

Then you drop the link in the group WhatsApp on the morning of the birthday and watch the chat. The Full Game is £45 for up to 8 people and the Director's Cut £79 for up to 14.

It isn't for everyone. If your mate would rather have a quiet pint than be the centre of attention for a day, book the pint. If they're the one who always tells the stories, they'll love being in one. See what a 40th birthday game looks like, or start on the home page.

See how it works